posts_gdocs: 1bsKetEVsp74m-l8vHJTvd7H8nDZVfew_2I42jAjp_qA
Data license: CC-BY
This data as json
| id | slug | type | content | published | createdAt | publishedAt | updatedAt | publicationContext | revisionId | breadcrumbs | markdown | title |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1bsKetEVsp74m-l8vHJTvd7H8nDZVfew_2I42jAjp_qA | do-better-cages-or-cage-free-environments-really-improve-the-lives-of-hens | article | {
"toc": [
{
"slug": "undefined-hens-in-cages-spend-most-of-their-life-in-pain-cage-free-systems-reduce-this-significantly",
"text": "Hens in cages spend most of their life in pain; cage-free systems reduce this significantly",
"title": "Hens in cages spend most of their life in pain; cage-free systems reduce this significantly",
"isSubheading": false
},
{
"slug": "undefined-what-causes-pain-in-egg-laying-hens",
"text": "What causes pain in egg-laying hens?",
"title": "What causes pain in egg-laying hens?",
"isSubheading": false
},
{
"slug": "undefined-going-cage-free-has-massive-welfare-benefits-but-going-egg-free-is-obviously-the-best-way-to-reduce-suffering",
"text": "Going cage-free has massive welfare benefits, but going egg-free is obviously the best way to reduce suffering",
"title": "Going cage-free has massive welfare benefits, but going egg-free is obviously the best way to reduce suffering",
"isSubheading": false
}
],
"body": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "There are around 8.3 billion egg-laying hens worldwide, around the same number as humans.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Most of these hens ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/number-of-laying-hens-in-cages-and-cage-free-housing",
"children": [
{
"text": "live in cages",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " that give them less space than an A4 sheet of paper.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It often has no nest to lay its eggs in; no room to rest; and its movement is almost entirely restricted. It can\u2019t carry out its normal behaviors of foraging, pecking, or dustbathing, so hens will often peck themselves or one another, leading to skin wounds and their feathers being plucked out. In many countries, chickens are \u2018",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debeaking",
"children": [
{
"text": "de-beaked",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": "\u2019 \u2013 where their beak is partially removed \u2013 to stop this.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Hens are bred to be highly productive. Hens will often lay around 300 eggs per year. That\u2019s very different from the wild ancestor of modern chickens \u2013 the red junglefowl \u2013 which lays around a dozen per year. And much higher than in 1900, when commercial hens would lay around 80 eggs yearly. The productive period of hens only lasts 12 to 18 months; they\u2019re then killed to make space for younger hens that can produce eggs at a higher rate. Male chicks \u2013 of no use to the intensive egg industry \u2013 are ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick_culling",
"children": [
{
"text": "often culled",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " in macerators shortly after birth.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "This is the harsh reality for billions of hens living in factory farms today. Objections to this practice are growing, and in some parts of the world, policies are changing.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In the graphic below, I\u2019ve shown the size of a standard battery cage per hen and compared the amount of space needed to do basic behaviors such as standing, turning, preening, and wing-flapping. As you can see, battery cages are too small for hens to perform any of these behaviors.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"size": "narrow",
"type": "image",
"filename": "size-battery-cage.png",
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In response to animal welfare concerns, some countries have banned ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "battery cages",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": ". The European Union ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://food.ec.europa.eu/animals/animal-welfare/animal-welfare-practice/animal-welfare-farm/laying-hens_en",
"children": [
{
"text": "banned them",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " in 2012.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-1",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "1",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Producers have since moved to \u2018",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "enriched cages",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "\u2019. These require laying hens to have at least 750 cm\u00b2 of space each. That\u2019s not much bigger than an A4 sheet of paper, which is 624 cm\u00b2. And as you can see in the chart above, the space is largely insufficient to perform basic behaviors such as tidying feathers and wing flapping. These regulations mandate that all hens \u201chave a nest, perching space, litter to allow pecking and scratching, and unrestricted access to a feed trough and drinking device\u201d.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "The EU now plans to ban the use ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297",
"children": [
{
"text": "of ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"children": [
{
"url": "https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297",
"children": [
{
"text": "any",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297",
"children": [
{
"text": "cage",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " by 2027. Many hens would therefore move to \u2018",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "cage-free aviary",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "\u2019 or ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "free-range",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": " systems. These systems are not necessarily the same: most free-range certifications require hens to access outdoor areas. This is often not the case in cage-free aviaries; they are mostly indoors.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "How much difference will this make to the welfare of chickens? Are enriched cages much better than battery cages, and will \u2018cage-free aviaries\u2019 provide them with a pain-free life?",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In this article, I look at the research and data on the estimated pain levels of hens in different production systems.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"text": [
{
"text": "Hens in cages spend most of their life in pain; cage-free systems reduce this significantly",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"type": "heading",
"level": 2,
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It\u2019s extremely hard to quantify pain levels in other animals. Doing this among humans is difficult enough since pain is subjective and can be experienced differently among individuals.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "To quantify pain in other animals, researchers can draw on various disciplines, including evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and pharmacology. Researchers Wladimir J. Alonso and Cynthia Schuck-Paim have written a detailed book on the analytical framework that is used to assess pain and discomfort felt by egg-laying hens [it\u2019s ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://welfarefootprint.org/book-laying-hens/",
"children": [
{
"text": "available for free",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": "].",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-2",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "2",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "The research organization ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"url": "https://welfarefootprint.org/research-projects/laying-hens/",
"children": [
{
"text": "Welfare Footprint",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " built on this work to present the number of hours of pain endured by hens in three production systems:",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "list",
"items": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Battery cages ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "house hens in cages with ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "very",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " restricted movement. Each hen has less area than an A4-sized sheet of paper. This is too small for hens to perform normal behaviors such as wing flapping and feather ruffling without hitting another hen.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Enriched cages ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "must give hens a minimum of 750 cm\u00b2 of space each. This is still very small. However, hens must have access to a nest, perching space, and a feeding and drinking area. Faunalytics provides a good ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://faunalytics.org/assessing-layer-hen-welfare-in-small-furnished-cages/",
"children": [
{
"text": "overview of furnished cages",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": ".",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Cage-free aviary systems",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": " are the most popular system for cage-free hens. Hens are given a non-enclosed system of \u2018tiers\u2019 \u2013 with ramps connecting levels \u2013 that allow them to move between them. There should be \u2018free space\u2019 \u2013 free of nests, perches, and feeding units on each level to ensure that hens are not restricted. ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Compassion in World Farming",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " gives a good ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://www.compassioninfoodbusiness.com/media/7436221/additional-guidance-on-multi-tier-systems-for-laying-hens.pdf",
"children": [
{
"text": "overview of cage-free aviaries",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": ", and how to increase their animal welfare benefits.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It evaluated the amount of time that the average hen spent in various levels of pain across its laying life.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-3",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "3",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " Here, the lifespan of hens in the different systems was assumed to be the same: 60 to 80 weeks before being slaughtered (with the first 20 weeks being a pre-laying phase, followed by 40 to 60 weeks of laying).",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-4",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "4",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It\u2019s not just the total hours of pain that matters. The intensity is just as \u2013 if not more \u2013 important. Many of us would rather spend 5 hours in mild pain than 1 hour in intense pain.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "This pain can be physical or psychological and is broken down into four ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "levels",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " of pain (from most to least intense):",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "list",
"items": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Excruciating: ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "this level of pain is intolerable, even for a few seconds. In humans, it is said to be the threshold that many people would choose to take their own lives rather than endure. Concealing the pain is impossible.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Disabling: ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "this level makes any type of enjoyment or positive welfare impossible. The pain is continuously distressing. Animals become much less attentive and responsive to things going on around them.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Hurtful: ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "this level disrupts animals from functioning optimally. It is difficult to draw attention away from the pain. There will be an awareness of the pain most of the time, with only brief periods of relief during particularly distracting activities. They can still perform everyday tasks such as eating and foraging but will have lower levels of motivation for less essential activities.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "Annoying: ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-bold"
},
{
"text": "the pain will be unpleasant but will not be intense enough to disrupt their everyday activities and routines. They should be able to ignore this pain most of the time.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In the chart, we can see the number of days spent at different intensities across the systems, as estimated by Schuck-Palm and Alonso. Estimates represent the total time in pain endured by the average hen due to each of the different harms and deprivations experienced. The researchers only considered the 16 hours per day that hens were awake. So when converting hours to days, I have divided by 16 rather than 24. That means the number of ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "waking ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": "days in pain is shown.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"url": "https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/pain-levels-hen-systems",
"type": "chart",
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "There is almost no difference in the time spent in excruciating pain between the systems. Hens endured this on average for around 3 minutes in all of them. As we\u2019ll see in the next section, the cause of this extreme pain was either fractures during transport or diseases that evolved into sepsis (generalized infection), such as acute peritonitis or a vent wound.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-5",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "5",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "But there is a large reduction in the amount of disabling, hurtful, and annoying pain within cage-free hens compared to caged ones. Disabling pain was reduced by 63%, hurtful by 57%, and annoying pain by 70%.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "So, it\u2019s not just that cage-free hens spend less time experiencing minor annoyances. They see significant reductions in disabling and pervasive levels of pain.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Moving a battery-caged hen to a furnished one will also make a significant difference in the time spent in disabling pain. But the reduction in hurtful and annoying pain is much less.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"text": [
{
"text": "What causes pain in egg-laying hens?",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"type": "heading",
"level": 2,
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In the chart below, we see the contributors to each level of pain for each production system.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Some of the largest contributors to pain in caged \u2013 particularly battery cage \u2013 systems is the lack of basic necessities such as a nest, roosting spot (where they rest and sleep), or space to forage. This is one of the biggest differences between caged and cage-free environments.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Keel bone fractures are another key source of pain. The bones of industrial egg-laying hens are much weaker and more brittle. One of the main explanations for this is that the intensity of egg-laying \u2013 where hens lay one almost daily for over a year \u2013 requires calcium. This calcium is thought to be partly taken from the hen\u2019s skeleton, which makes it more fragile.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-6",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "6",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " This makes them very susceptible to fractures.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Surprisingly, it has been suggested that it\u2019s hens in cage-free environments that are at the greatest risk of keel bone fractures, although there are recent studies that contest this.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-7",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "7",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " If fracture risk ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "is",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " higher in cage-free hens, it may be because they have more space to move and fly, making them more likely to collide with obstacles, leading to injuries. In caged environments, hens have much less space to move, and the likelihood of high-speed collisions is much lower.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "That is a key point from this analysis: while the conditions for hens in cage-free settings are better than in caged ones, they still experience significant pain and discomfort because they are still bred and raised to be highly productive. This rate of egg production has significant costs for their health and welfare.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"text": [
{
"text": "Breakdown of the causes of pain in egg-laying hens between different production systems. Source: ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://welfarefootprint.org/research-projects/laying-hens/",
"children": [
{
"text": "Welfare Footprint",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": ".",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"type": "heading",
"level": 5,
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"size": "wide",
"type": "image",
"filename": "laying-hens-pain.png",
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"text": [
{
"text": "Going cage-free has massive welfare benefits, but going egg-free is obviously the best way to reduce suffering",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"type": "heading",
"level": 2,
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It is a good thing for animal welfare for the EU to ban all caged environments over the next five years.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "As we\u2019ve seen, moving to cage-free aviaries reduces suffering significantly. Multiply this by the number of hens in the world \u2013 8.3 billion \u2013 and we can see how large the welfare benefits would be if all countries did the same.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "But going cage-free does not put an end to this suffering. These hens will still spend more than a third of the year in pain or discomfort, often because of the pressures of producing eggs so intensively.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "This is clear from the research.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-8",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "8",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " Few studies attempt to quantify pain in the way that Schuck-Paim and Alonso do, but there are others that evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of different production systems. Cage-free systems improve welfare by allowing hens to perform natural and basic behaviors that they wouldn\u2019t be able to \u2013 such as perching, flapping, and moving freely. But they may be at higher risk of fractures.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-9",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "9",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " The welfare of hens in these systems ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://animalcharityevaluators.org/research/research-briefs/what-is-the-effect-of-cage-free-corporate-outreach-on-egg-laying-hens-welfare/",
"children": [
{
"text": "can also be more variable",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " and depends on the experience of the farmer to set up their environments appropriately.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Finally, there have been a number of studies that suggest that ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "mortality",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " rates ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://www.openphilanthropy.org/research/how-will-hen-welfare-be-impacted-by-the-transition-to-cage-free-housing/#2-investigation-into-mortality-rates",
"children": [
{
"text": "are higher in cage-free",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " settings. Now, mortality rates are not necessarily the most direct measure of levels of pain \u2013 since most of a hen\u2019s suffering will occur during its laying life \u2013 but it\u2019s still an important metric to consider. Hens might have higher mortality rates in cage-free settings due to collisions with objects; more aggressive pecking or social behavior; or exposure to manure or infections. A large meta-analysis on this question found that the experience or maturity of the cage-free setting was important: mortality rates can be higher for inexperienced producers.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "#note-10",
"children": [
{
"children": [
{
"text": "10",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-superscript"
}
],
"spanType": "span-ref"
},
{
"text": " But mortality rates fall over time as producers build knowledge. And in experienced systems, mortality rates are not higher than in cages.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Overall, the research suggests strong welfare benefits in moving from caged to cage-free environments. As a consumer, you can reduce animal suffering by opting for cage-free eggs. But better still, you can reduce or eliminate them from your diet entirely.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "horizontal-rule",
"value": {},
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"text": [
{
"text": "Acknowledgments",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"type": "heading",
"level": 5,
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "I would like to thank Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Max Roser, and Pablo Rosado for their valuable comments and suggestions on this article.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"refs": {
"errors": [],
"definitions": {
"2b242d0638b0f991783723792f2858da52cd7759": {
"id": "2b242d0638b0f991783723792f2858da52cd7759",
"index": 0,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "The Directive to ban battery cages was agreed in 1999 but did not outlaw them until 2012.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"499316cfce93596d210cab5db1e467cf0a72798f": {
"id": "499316cfce93596d210cab5db1e467cf0a72798f",
"index": 5,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "There are various other potential explanations for why hens are so susceptible to fractures. One is that their bone density is highly correlated with the age at which they first lay eggs (i.e., their \u2018puberty age\u2019). If hens lay eggs too early \u2013 which is often the case for industrial ones \u2013 then their bones are unlikely to have formed properly.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "This paper by Toscano et al. (2020) discussed these explanations in detail.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Toscano, M. J., Dunn, I. C., Christensen, J. P., Petow, S., Kittelsen, K., & Ulrich, R. (2020). Explanations for keel bone fractures in laying hens: are there explanations in addition to elevated egg production? Poultry science, 99(9), 4183-4194.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"6d369f05e956c43b8b13b62100c88789c9281957": {
"id": "6d369f05e956c43b8b13b62100c88789c9281957",
"index": 6,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Rufener, C., & Makagon, M. M. (2020). Keel bone fractures in laying hens: a systematic review of prevalence across age, housing systems, and strains. Journal of Animal Science, 98(Supplement_1), S36-S51.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"77d3921bbc5476cd81d956b95aa401c34c80f27e": {
"id": "77d3921bbc5476cd81d956b95aa401c34c80f27e",
"index": 1,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "The authors stress that this is an evolving area of research with existing knowledge gaps and uncertainty around various input parameters.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"a1b7fbea58de116d49866c6bc357ddd881762dd6": {
"id": "a1b7fbea58de116d49866c6bc357ddd881762dd6",
"index": 9,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Schuck-Paim, C., Negro-Calduch, E. & Alonso, W.J. Laying hen mortality in different indoor housing systems: a meta-analysis of data from commercial farms in 16 countries. Sci Rep 11, 3052 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-81868-3.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"a7c0136b1bfd046e52d16e2eacd98cae35c3c75b": {
"id": "a7c0136b1bfd046e52d16e2eacd98cae35c3c75b",
"index": 8,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Hartcher, K. M., & Jones, B. (2017). The welfare of layer hens in cage and cage-free housing systems. World's Poultry Science Journal, 73(4), 767-782.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"b791d6a766d38a4b1dded451bec4f98a06c74939": {
"id": "b791d6a766d38a4b1dded451bec4f98a06c74939",
"index": 3,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "In reality, the lifespan of caged hens might be higher. In some countries (outside Europe, where the practice is banned), producers try to extend the productive life of hens using a practice called \u2018induced molting\u2019, where feed is typically withdrawn for several days. This practice is ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-81868-3",
"children": [
{
"text": "much more common",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-link"
},
{
"text": " in caged than cage-free settings. This might mean the total hours of suffering for a caged hen are even greater than the results below show.\u000b\u000bSchuck-Paim, C., Negro-Calduch, E., & Alonso, W. J. (2021). Laying hen mortality in different indoor housing systems: a meta-analysis of data from commercial farms in 16 countries. Scientific Reports, 11(1), 3052.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"c0ab8065e75c0bf5f0300decb9ae532ed0c819f7": {
"id": "c0ab8065e75c0bf5f0300decb9ae532ed0c819f7",
"index": 7,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Appleby, M. C., & Hughes, B. O. (1991). Welfare of laying hens in cages and alternative systems: environmental, physical and behavioural aspects. World's Poultry Science Journal, 47(2), 109-128.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"e87f7197c84c7658a8b3f60c18298a92743c1d07": {
"id": "e87f7197c84c7658a8b3f60c18298a92743c1d07",
"index": 2,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "It\u2019s extremely difficult to quantify this individually since specific hens could have different experiences, injuries, and pain tolerances. So this metric is typically employed at the population level and then given as the average for an individual. As an example, if a hen that has a keel fracture experiences 10 hours of pain, and 70% of the population experiences a keel fracture, then the average pain noted is 7 hours per hen. That doesn\u2019t mean ",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
},
{
"children": [
{
"text": "every",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"spanType": "span-italic"
},
{
"text": " hen will experience 7 hours of pain; some will experience more, and some not at all.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
},
"e96af2277ec59fa4a95d0542e6b459b0757670a6": {
"id": "e96af2277ec59fa4a95d0542e6b459b0757670a6",
"index": 4,
"content": [
{
"type": "text",
"value": [
{
"text": "Egg yolk peritonitis is where a yolk is formed, but the full egg is not. This means the yolk is \u2018laid\u2019 internally within the hen\u2019s abdomen. It forms a swollen and painful abdomen, often leading to breathing problems. This can develop into sepsis, a likely painful condition, and ultimately prove fatal.",
"spanType": "span-simple-text"
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
],
"parseErrors": []
}
}
},
"type": "article",
"title": "Do better cages or cage-free environments really improve the lives of hens?",
"authors": [
"Hannah Ritchie"
],
"excerpt": "Research suggests that moving hens from battery cages to cage-free environments reduces the time animals spend in pain substantially.",
"dateline": "September 25, 2023",
"subtitle": "Research suggests that moving hens from battery cages to cage-free environments reduces the time animals spend in pain substantially.",
"featured-image": "Battery-hens-thumbnail.png"
} |
1 | 2023-07-27 14:06:28 | 2023-09-25 05:37:11 | 2023-12-28 16:31:05 | unlisted | ALBJ4LsCWrbqVse6--TmB8q09iPXZOdT_gGqY0ZM-Qe8e_UlgmrcPia0hLtWfO8F_A8L62GiDz_AQrrj7vAX5g | [
{
"href": "/animal-welfare",
"label": "Animal Welfare"
},
{
"label": "Cage-free hens"
}
] |
There are around 8.3 billion egg-laying hens worldwide, around the same number as humans. Most of these hens [live in cages](https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/number-of-laying-hens-in-cages-and-cage-free-housing) that give them less space than an A4 sheet of paper. It often has no nest to lay its eggs in; no room to rest; and its movement is almost entirely restricted. It can’t carry out its normal behaviors of foraging, pecking, or dustbathing, so hens will often peck themselves or one another, leading to skin wounds and their feathers being plucked out. In many countries, chickens are ‘[de-beaked](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debeaking)’ – where their beak is partially removed – to stop this. Hens are bred to be highly productive. Hens will often lay around 300 eggs per year. That’s very different from the wild ancestor of modern chickens – the red junglefowl – which lays around a dozen per year. And much higher than in 1900, when commercial hens would lay around 80 eggs yearly. The productive period of hens only lasts 12 to 18 months; they’re then killed to make space for younger hens that can produce eggs at a higher rate. Male chicks – of no use to the intensive egg industry – are [often culled](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick_culling) in macerators shortly after birth. This is the harsh reality for billions of hens living in factory farms today. Objections to this practice are growing, and in some parts of the world, policies are changing. In the graphic below, I’ve shown the size of a standard battery cage per hen and compared the amount of space needed to do basic behaviors such as standing, turning, preening, and wing-flapping. As you can see, battery cages are too small for hens to perform any of these behaviors. <Image filename="size-battery-cage.png"/> In response to animal welfare concerns, some countries have banned **battery cages**. The European Union [banned them](https://food.ec.europa.eu/animals/animal-welfare/animal-welfare-practice/animal-welfare-farm/laying-hens_en) in 2012.1 Producers have since moved to ‘**enriched cages**’. These require laying hens to have at least 750 cm² of space each. That’s not much bigger than an A4 sheet of paper, which is 624 cm². And as you can see in the chart above, the space is largely insufficient to perform basic behaviors such as tidying feathers and wing flapping. These regulations mandate that all hens “have a nest, perching space, litter to allow pecking and scratching, and unrestricted access to a feed trough and drinking device”. The EU now plans to ban the use [of ](https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297)_[any](https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297)_ [cage](https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_3297) by 2027. Many hens would therefore move to ‘**cage-free aviary**’ or **free-range** systems. These systems are not necessarily the same: most free-range certifications require hens to access outdoor areas. This is often not the case in cage-free aviaries; they are mostly indoors. How much difference will this make to the welfare of chickens? Are enriched cages much better than battery cages, and will ‘cage-free aviaries’ provide them with a pain-free life? In this article, I look at the research and data on the estimated pain levels of hens in different production systems. ## Hens in cages spend most of their life in pain; cage-free systems reduce this significantly It’s extremely hard to quantify pain levels in other animals. Doing this among humans is difficult enough since pain is subjective and can be experienced differently among individuals. To quantify pain in other animals, researchers can draw on various disciplines, including evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and pharmacology. Researchers Wladimir J. Alonso and Cynthia Schuck-Paim have written a detailed book on the analytical framework that is used to assess pain and discomfort felt by egg-laying hens [it’s [available for free](https://welfarefootprint.org/book-laying-hens/)].2 The research organization _[Welfare Footprint](https://welfarefootprint.org/research-projects/laying-hens/)_ built on this work to present the number of hours of pain endured by hens in three production systems: * **Battery cages **house hens in cages with _very_ restricted movement. Each hen has less area than an A4-sized sheet of paper. This is too small for hens to perform normal behaviors such as wing flapping and feather ruffling without hitting another hen. * **Enriched cages **must give hens a minimum of 750 cm² of space each. This is still very small. However, hens must have access to a nest, perching space, and a feeding and drinking area. Faunalytics provides a good [overview of furnished cages](https://faunalytics.org/assessing-layer-hen-welfare-in-small-furnished-cages/). * **Cage-free aviary systems** are the most popular system for cage-free hens. Hens are given a non-enclosed system of ‘tiers’ – with ramps connecting levels – that allow them to move between them. There should be ‘free space’ – free of nests, perches, and feeding units on each level to ensure that hens are not restricted. _Compassion in World Farming_ gives a good [overview of cage-free aviaries](https://www.compassioninfoodbusiness.com/media/7436221/additional-guidance-on-multi-tier-systems-for-laying-hens.pdf), and how to increase their animal welfare benefits. It evaluated the amount of time that the average hen spent in various levels of pain across its laying life.3 Here, the lifespan of hens in the different systems was assumed to be the same: 60 to 80 weeks before being slaughtered (with the first 20 weeks being a pre-laying phase, followed by 40 to 60 weeks of laying).4 It’s not just the total hours of pain that matters. The intensity is just as – if not more – important. Many of us would rather spend 5 hours in mild pain than 1 hour in intense pain. This pain can be physical or psychological and is broken down into four _levels_ of pain (from most to least intense): * **Excruciating: **this level of pain is intolerable, even for a few seconds. In humans, it is said to be the threshold that many people would choose to take their own lives rather than endure. Concealing the pain is impossible. * **Disabling: **this level makes any type of enjoyment or positive welfare impossible. The pain is continuously distressing. Animals become much less attentive and responsive to things going on around them. * **Hurtful: **this level disrupts animals from functioning optimally. It is difficult to draw attention away from the pain. There will be an awareness of the pain most of the time, with only brief periods of relief during particularly distracting activities. They can still perform everyday tasks such as eating and foraging but will have lower levels of motivation for less essential activities. * **Annoying: **the pain will be unpleasant but will not be intense enough to disrupt their everyday activities and routines. They should be able to ignore this pain most of the time. In the chart, we can see the number of days spent at different intensities across the systems, as estimated by Schuck-Palm and Alonso. Estimates represent the total time in pain endured by the average hen due to each of the different harms and deprivations experienced. The researchers only considered the 16 hours per day that hens were awake. So when converting hours to days, I have divided by 16 rather than 24. That means the number of _waking _days in pain is shown. <Chart url="https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/pain-levels-hen-systems"/> There is almost no difference in the time spent in excruciating pain between the systems. Hens endured this on average for around 3 minutes in all of them. As we’ll see in the next section, the cause of this extreme pain was either fractures during transport or diseases that evolved into sepsis (generalized infection), such as acute peritonitis or a vent wound.5 But there is a large reduction in the amount of disabling, hurtful, and annoying pain within cage-free hens compared to caged ones. Disabling pain was reduced by 63%, hurtful by 57%, and annoying pain by 70%. So, it’s not just that cage-free hens spend less time experiencing minor annoyances. They see significant reductions in disabling and pervasive levels of pain. Moving a battery-caged hen to a furnished one will also make a significant difference in the time spent in disabling pain. But the reduction in hurtful and annoying pain is much less. ## What causes pain in egg-laying hens? In the chart below, we see the contributors to each level of pain for each production system. Some of the largest contributors to pain in caged – particularly battery cage – systems is the lack of basic necessities such as a nest, roosting spot (where they rest and sleep), or space to forage. This is one of the biggest differences between caged and cage-free environments. Keel bone fractures are another key source of pain. The bones of industrial egg-laying hens are much weaker and more brittle. One of the main explanations for this is that the intensity of egg-laying – where hens lay one almost daily for over a year – requires calcium. This calcium is thought to be partly taken from the hen’s skeleton, which makes it more fragile.6 This makes them very susceptible to fractures. Surprisingly, it has been suggested that it’s hens in cage-free environments that are at the greatest risk of keel bone fractures, although there are recent studies that contest this.7 If fracture risk _is_ higher in cage-free hens, it may be because they have more space to move and fly, making them more likely to collide with obstacles, leading to injuries. In caged environments, hens have much less space to move, and the likelihood of high-speed collisions is much lower. That is a key point from this analysis: while the conditions for hens in cage-free settings are better than in caged ones, they still experience significant pain and discomfort because they are still bred and raised to be highly productive. This rate of egg production has significant costs for their health and welfare. ##### Breakdown of the causes of pain in egg-laying hens between different production systems. Source: [Welfare Footprint](https://welfarefootprint.org/research-projects/laying-hens/). <Image filename="laying-hens-pain.png"/> ## Going cage-free has massive welfare benefits, but going egg-free is obviously the best way to reduce suffering It is a good thing for animal welfare for the EU to ban all caged environments over the next five years. As we’ve seen, moving to cage-free aviaries reduces suffering significantly. Multiply this by the number of hens in the world – 8.3 billion – and we can see how large the welfare benefits would be if all countries did the same. But going cage-free does not put an end to this suffering. These hens will still spend more than a third of the year in pain or discomfort, often because of the pressures of producing eggs so intensively. This is clear from the research.8 Few studies attempt to quantify pain in the way that Schuck-Paim and Alonso do, but there are others that evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of different production systems. Cage-free systems improve welfare by allowing hens to perform natural and basic behaviors that they wouldn’t be able to – such as perching, flapping, and moving freely. But they may be at higher risk of fractures.9 The welfare of hens in these systems [can also be more variable](https://animalcharityevaluators.org/research/research-briefs/what-is-the-effect-of-cage-free-corporate-outreach-on-egg-laying-hens-welfare/) and depends on the experience of the farmer to set up their environments appropriately. Finally, there have been a number of studies that suggest that _mortality_ rates [are higher in cage-free](https://www.openphilanthropy.org/research/how-will-hen-welfare-be-impacted-by-the-transition-to-cage-free-housing/#2-investigation-into-mortality-rates) settings. Now, mortality rates are not necessarily the most direct measure of levels of pain – since most of a hen’s suffering will occur during its laying life – but it’s still an important metric to consider. Hens might have higher mortality rates in cage-free settings due to collisions with objects; more aggressive pecking or social behavior; or exposure to manure or infections. A large meta-analysis on this question found that the experience or maturity of the cage-free setting was important: mortality rates can be higher for inexperienced producers.10 But mortality rates fall over time as producers build knowledge. And in experienced systems, mortality rates are not higher than in cages. Overall, the research suggests strong welfare benefits in moving from caged to cage-free environments. As a consumer, you can reduce animal suffering by opting for cage-free eggs. But better still, you can reduce or eliminate them from your diet entirely. --- ##### Acknowledgments I would like to thank Cynthia Schuck-Paim, Max Roser, and Pablo Rosado for their valuable comments and suggestions on this article. The Directive to ban battery cages was agreed in 1999 but did not outlaw them until 2012. There are various other potential explanations for why hens are so susceptible to fractures. One is that their bone density is highly correlated with the age at which they first lay eggs (i.e., their ‘puberty age’). If hens lay eggs too early – which is often the case for industrial ones – then their bones are unlikely to have formed properly. This paper by Toscano et al. (2020) discussed these explanations in detail. Toscano, M. J., Dunn, I. C., Christensen, J. P., Petow, S., Kittelsen, K., & Ulrich, R. (2020). Explanations for keel bone fractures in laying hens: are there explanations in addition to elevated egg production? Poultry science, 99(9), 4183-4194. Rufener, C., & Makagon, M. M. (2020). Keel bone fractures in laying hens: a systematic review of prevalence across age, housing systems, and strains. Journal of Animal Science, 98(Supplement_1), S36-S51. The authors stress that this is an evolving area of research with existing knowledge gaps and uncertainty around various input parameters. Schuck-Paim, C., Negro-Calduch, E. & Alonso, W.J. Laying hen mortality in different indoor housing systems: a meta-analysis of data from commercial farms in 16 countries. Sci Rep 11, 3052 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-81868-3. Hartcher, K. M., & Jones, B. (2017). The welfare of layer hens in cage and cage-free housing systems. World's Poultry Science Journal, 73(4), 767-782. In reality, the lifespan of caged hens might be higher. In some countries (outside Europe, where the practice is banned), producers try to extend the productive life of hens using a practice called ‘induced molting’, where feed is typically withdrawn for several days. This practice is [much more common](https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-81868-3) in caged than cage-free settings. This might mean the total hours of suffering for a caged hen are even greater than the results below show. Schuck-Paim, C., Negro-Calduch, E., & Alonso, W. J. (2021). Laying hen mortality in different indoor housing systems: a meta-analysis of data from commercial farms in 16 countries. Scientific Reports, 11(1), 3052. Appleby, M. C., & Hughes, B. O. (1991). Welfare of laying hens in cages and alternative systems: environmental, physical and behavioural aspects. World's Poultry Science Journal, 47(2), 109-128. It’s extremely difficult to quantify this individually since specific hens could have different experiences, injuries, and pain tolerances. So this metric is typically employed at the population level and then given as the average for an individual. As an example, if a hen that has a keel fracture experiences 10 hours of pain, and 70% of the population experiences a keel fracture, then the average pain noted is 7 hours per hen. That doesn’t mean _every_ hen will experience 7 hours of pain; some will experience more, and some not at all. Egg yolk peritonitis is where a yolk is formed, but the full egg is not. This means the yolk is ‘laid’ internally within the hen’s abdomen. It forms a swollen and painful abdomen, often leading to breathing problems. This can develop into sepsis, a likely painful condition, and ultimately prove fatal. | Do better cages or cage-free environments really improve the lives of hens? |